
The laugh of the day is the heavy breathing Sue Reid in the Daily Mail. She has become aware of:
The Lancashire blacksmith’s son and leader of the Communist Party of Great Britain
and his malign influence over all things left-of-centre in Britain.
Let us all help Ms Reid with a rousing chorus:
Harry was a Bolshie, one of Stalin’s lads,
Till he was foully murdered by reactionary cads…
Ah, those were the days!
But it gets better!
Labour leaders Michael Foot and Neil Kinnock colluded with the Soviet communists to try to beat their ‘common enemy’, Margaret Thatcher.
and
the political ideology of so many of those who govern us today was shaped by the unspeakable communist creed of the Soviet Union.
Gosh! No bodice remained unripped!
There’s only a couple of problems there: most of us who’ve read the odd history could adequately speak the “communist creed of the Soviet Union”. Moreover, the “creed” seemed to change with remarkable rapidity between one generation of Soviet leaders and the next.
What’s more interesting is where Ms Reid came across this amazing intelligence. Was it a neck-and-crop race across the Arctic tundra, with wolves nipping at the troika every verst of the way? Then years of patient trawling through the archives of the former Soviet Union? Well, probably not: more likely she nipped into WH Smith and bought the current issue of The Spectator.
There she would have found an article by Pavel Stroilov, with “Additional reporting by Dasha Afanasieva.” Curiously, there is absolutely no acknowledgement of this in the Mail. Anyone wanting to by-pass Ms Reid and get the original Stroilov can do so on-line.
Some innocent fun can be had by comparing the two versions:
Stroilov:
On the whole, however, the communist infiltration of the T&G is hardly a joking matter: its influence in the Labour party was substantial. The decision to give Gordon Brown his first and only safe seat, Dunfermline East, was made by two T&G officials: Hugh Wyper, the regional boss and a Communist Party member, and Alec Kitson. This is not exceptional. Neil Kinnock, Tony Blair, Margaret Beckett, Harriet Harman, John Reid — to name just a few — were all T&G people who made their Labour party careers thanks to the union’s backing.
Reid:
It is not just the Left’s close connection with the Soviet Union, but the lasting influence of that connection that should concern us all…
The decision to give the young Scotsman [Gordon Brown] his first and only safe seat, Dunfermline East, was made by two TGWU senior officials – one of them was Jack Jones, the other the drunken Alec Kitson. Both were friends of the Kremlin.
The union’s patronage was ubiquitous. Neil Kinnock and Tony Blair, as well as Cabinet ministers Margaret Beckett, Harriet Harman and John Reid, were all sponsored by TGWU and made their Labour Party careers thanks to it.
Spot any coincidences?
There is one great similarity between the two (apart from being right-wing hatchet-jobs): both Stroilov and Reid agree on their single source:
Stroilov:
It is almost 20 years since the fall of the Berlin Wall — and still the truth keeps trickling out of Moscow. The Soviets, like the Nazis, were meticulous note-keepers and there is decades worth of material still to be uncovered. At first, only those who went through the filing cabinets could compile the untold stories of the USSR. But now that these records are being digitised, scrutinising them becomes a lot easier. And this is how I came across the extraordinary diaries of Anatoly Chernyaev.
For years he was the Soviet Union’s contact man with the West. But from the 1970s onwards he met the British politicians who went looking for favours behind the Iron Curtain — and recorded every encounter in his journal. He was a deputy in the Soviet International Department (a successor to the Comintern) and latterly an adviser to Gorbachev himself. His diaries in the Gorbachev era have been translated in Washington. But his liaisons with British politicians in the Cold War era have never been made fully public — until now.
Reid:
Just how deep the tentacles of communism reached into the heart of British government has now been revealed with the emergence of an extraordinary diary by Anatoly Chernyaev, the Soviet Union’s contact man with the West at the icy height of the Cold War.
Meticulously detailed and written by hand on lined notepaper, the diary has come to light in the U.S. National Security Archive.
Except that’s not quite true, in either case
Chernyaev’s diary has been available for some time. Extracts have been dribbling out of the American National Security Archives, courtesy of George Washington University, since May 2006.
The real question raised by Stroilov and little lap-dog Reid is: Why now?
As for the historical significance of Harry Pollitt, it lies less in any stamps issued by the Soviet, or war-ships named in his honour, and more in where he ended up:
He got up to the Pearly Gates, met Peter on his knees
‘May I speak to Comrade God I’m Harold Pollitt please …Said Peter unto Harry: ‘Are you humble and contrite?’
‘I’m a friend of Lady Docker’s’, ‘Then OK. you’ll be alright!’ …
Alas, his time in the Elysian Fields was swiftly terminated:
One day as God was walking around the heavenly state
Who should he see but Harry chalking slogans on the gate…They put him up for trial before the Holy Ghost
Charged with disaffection amongst the heavenly host …The verdict it was guilty, said Harry ‘That is swell’
And he tucked his nightie ’round his knees and he floated down to hell …A few more years have ended, now Harry’s doing swell
He’s just been made the people’s commissar for Soviet Socialist Hell!
In all truth, everybody on the British Left took Harry and the CPGB with more than a pinch of salt. By the ’50s they were a select body: those who made it in the unions did so by being effective for their members — and their political ties were well-known. Hardly a national menace there, unless one needed an instant bogeyman from whom to hang a headline. Earlier still, any promiscuity with the Red Shed laid one open to a flea in or a clip around the ear from that other T&G leftie, Ernie Bevin. Apart from anything else, it was well recognised that some half of the King Street stalwarts were also on the pay-roll of MI5.
As for a real traitor, well … there was the pre-War owner of the Daily Mail. Or, in the case of Kim “Stanley” Philby, he was working for the Observer. Or in the case of Anthony “Johnson” Blunt for Buckingham Palace.
Posted by Malcolm Redfellow
Posted by Malcolm Redfellow 
olm wishes he had previously appreciated such a philosophical gem. He would have deployed it and so avoided the need to allocate memory cells to the historical importance of the Treaties of Westphalia (1648), Paris (1815), Versailles (1919) and, oh!, so many more. Malcolm ruefully doubts the ploy would have impressed the examiners at Irish Leaving Certificate or the University of Dublin, however. Obviously they really “do different” (as left) at
Posted by Malcolm Redfellow
Dr Hilary Jones writes